Stutz was one of the best pitchers in SHC baseball history. He is still in the top 5 of many categories for career records including wins (26), saves (7), innings pitched (322.1) and single game strikeouts (13). He was named co-captain of the baseball team in 1992. An All-GCAC selection in 1992, Stutz anchored the SHC pitching staff that year and helped win a school record 40 games and the NAIA District 30 Championship advancing to the NAIA Tournament.